Understanding Residential Property Flipping Rules in Canada

The real estate market in Canada has undergone significant regulatory changes to address property flipping. Two key measures are the federal CRA Residential Property Flipping Rule and British Columbia’s BC Home Flipping Tax (effective January 1, 2025). These rules aim to curb speculative property transactions and ensure appropriate taxation of profits derived from flipping activities. Below, we discuss each rule in detail.


Federal CRA Residential Property Flipping Rule

The CRA Residential Property Flipping Rule, effective for dispositions after 2022, targets individuals or entities engaged in buying and selling residential properties for profit within a short time frame. Under this rule:

  • Definition: A “flipped property” is any residential property in Canada that was owned for less than 365 days before its sale.
  • Tax Treatment:
    • The entire gain from the disposition of such property is classified as business income, irrespective of the seller’s intention.
    • The 50% capital gains inclusion rate does not apply.
    • The principal residence exemption cannot be claimed.
  • Scope: The rule also applies to rights to acquire residential property, such as pre-construction condominium assignments.
  • Deductible Expenses: Reasonable expenses incurred to earn income are deductible, but losses cannot be claimed as business losses.

Exceptions to the Rule

The following life events exempt sellers from the rule:

  • Death
  • Marital breakdown
  • Addition of family members
  • Disability
  • Eligible work relocation (over 40 km closer to the new work location)
  • Involuntary termination of employment
  • Insolvency
  • Threat to personal safety
  • Destruction or expropriation of the property

Cases Not Subject to the Rule

If the property is held for over a year or falls under one of the exceptions, the facts of the case determine whether the gain is treated as business income or a capital gain. Key factors include:

  • Intention at the time of purchase
  • Length of ownership
  • Taxpayer’s profession or business
  • Frequency of similar transactions

Increased Capital Gains Tax Rate

Effective June 25, 2024, the proportion of capital gains that are taxable increases from 50% to 66.7% for:

  • Net capital gains exceeding $250,000 per year for individuals.
  • All net gains realized by corporations and most types of trusts.

BC Home Flipping Tax (2025)

British Columbia introduced the BC Home Flipping Tax under the Residential Property (Short-Term Holding) Profit Tax Act, effective January 1, 2025. This provincial measure complements the federal rule and targets short-term residential property transactions in BC.

Applicability and Scope

  1. Taxable Properties:
    • Residential properties with housing units or zoned for residential use.
    • Rights to acquire such properties, including presale contracts for condos.
  2. Ownership Period:
    • Properties owned for less than 730 days before sale are subject to the tax.
    • Ownership starts from the date of purchase or presale contract signing.

Exemptions to the BC Home Flipping Tax

  1. Life Events
    The following personal circumstances allow individuals to sell their property without incurring the BC Home Flipping Tax:
    • Death of the Owner: The tax is waived for sales related to the death of the property owner.
    • Marital Breakdown: If the sale occurs as part of a separation or divorce, the exemption applies.
    • Addition of Family Members: Growing households may need to sell due to the birth or adoption of children.
  2. Health-Related Reasons
    • Disability: If the property owner or an immediate family member develops a disability that necessitates a move (e.g., to an accessible home), the tax does not apply.
    • Serious Illness: Moving due to health reasons, such as accessing specialized care, is exempt from the tax.
  3. Employment-Driven Moves
    • Eligible Work Relocation: A move that brings the seller at least 40 kilometers closer to a new work location qualifies for an exemption.
    • Involuntary Termination of Employment: Job loss leading to financial hardship and the need to sell is exempt.
  4. Financial Distress
    • Insolvency or Bankruptcy: Sales triggered by insolvency or bankruptcy are exempt.
    • Foreclosure or Power of Sale: If the property is sold to satisfy a mortgage lender, the tax does not apply.
  5. Safety and Legal Concerns
    • Threat to Personal Safety: Situations involving domestic violence, threats, or safety concerns are exempt.
    • Property Expropriation: If the property is expropriated by a government or authority, the tax is waived.
    • Destruction or Substantial Damage: Sales of properties damaged by natural disasters (e.g., floods, wildfires, or earthquakes) are not subject to the tax.
  6. Specific Transactions Excluded
    • Gifts or Transfers: Transfers between family members or as gifts are excluded.
    • Mortgage Transactions: Sales involving mortgage adjustments, such as renewals or refinancing, are not taxed.
    • Deemed Dispositions: Transactions treated as deemed dispositions under the federal Income Tax Act are also exempt.

Documentation Requirements

To qualify for these exemptions, sellers may need to provide supporting evidence, such as:

  • Medical or legal records for health-related exemptions.
  • Employment letters or relocation agreements for job-related moves.
  • Death certificates or divorce decrees for personal circumstances.
  • Insurance claims or government notices for damaged properties.

By clearly defining these exemptions, the BC government ensures that the tax targets speculative transactions while protecting those selling out of necessity.

Tax Calculation

  1. Rate:
    • 20% on net taxable income for properties sold within 365 days.
    • Decreases gradually over the next 365 days.
  2. Days of Ownership:
    • Count begins from the purchase date (e.g., closing date) to the sale date.
    • For presale contracts, the date of contract signing applies.

Comparative Example: Taxpayer Sarah’s BC and Alberta Transactions

Scenario:

  • Sarah purchases a property in British Columbia (BC) on January 1, 2025, for $500,000 and sells it on December 30, 2025 for $700,000 (ownership period: 364 days).
  • She also purchases a property in Alberta (AB) on January 1, 2025, for $500,000 and sells it on December 30, 2025 for $700,000.

BC Property

1. BC Home Flipping Tax:

  • Profit Calculation:
    $700,000 (sale price) – $500,000 (purchase price) – $20,000 (selling and legal costs) = $180,000.
  • Tax Rate:
    Since the property is sold within 365 days, the BC Home Flipping Tax rate is 20%.
  • Tax Payable:
    $180,000 × 20% = $36,000.

2. Federal Residential Property Flipping Rule:

  • Profit Calculation:
    $180,000 (same as above).
  • Tax Treatment:
    Classified as business income under the CRA rule.
  • Federal Tax Payable:
    Assuming a marginal tax rate of 40%, $180,000 × 40% = $72,000.

Total BC Property Tax Liability:

  • BC Home Flipping Tax: $36,000
  • Federal Tax: $72,000
  • Total: $108,000

Alberta Property

1. Provincial Flipping Tax:

  • Alberta does not impose a flipping tax.

2. Federal Residential Property Flipping Rule:

  • Profit Calculation:
    $700,000 (sale price) – $500,000 (purchase price) – $20,000 (selling and legal costs) = $180,000.
  • Tax Treatment:
    Classified as business income under the CRA rule.
  • Federal Tax Payable:
    Assuming a marginal tax rate of 40%, $180,000 × 40% = $72,000.

Total Alberta Property Tax Liability:

  • Provincial Flipping Tax: $0
  • Federal Tax: $72,000
  • Total: $72,000

Comparative Summary

CategoryBC PropertyAlberta Property
Profit$180,000$180,000
Provincial Flipping Tax$36,000$0
Federal Tax$72,000$72,000
Total Tax$108,000$72,000

Recordkeeping and Compliance

Both CRA and BC authorities emphasize thorough documentation for compliance. Retain:

  • Purchase and sale agreements.
  • Invoices for renovations or repairs.
  • Evidence supporting exemptions (e.g., work relocation records).
  • Correspondence with real estate agents.

These updated rules reflect growing efforts to discourage speculative property activities and ensure fair taxation. Whether under federal CRA rules or BC’s home flipping tax, understanding the nuances of these regulations is crucial for compliance and financial planning.

448 Views

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *